Now lets check the top 10 smartphone in market.
1. T-Mobile myTouch 3G Slide
An Android smartphone for first-time users
- Superb QWERTY keyboard
- Easy-to-use interface
- Good call quality
- Clunky slider mechanism
- Sub-par camera
- Weak battery
Review:
The T-Mobile MyTouch 3G Slide is an entry-level Android device geared for first-time smartphone users. Reviewers praise its midrange feature set, top-notch QWERTY keyboard and exceptional ease of use. Chris Ziegler at Engadget.com considers it "among the best" QWERTY Android sliders, and CNET's Bonnie Cha says T-Mobile's customized user interface "brings a more consumer-friendly look and feel" to Android. However, experts also say the Slide's features can't compete with powerhouses like the HTC Droid Incredible (Free with contract) or HTC EVO 4G (*Est. $190 with contract). Nevertheless, for those transitioning to smartphones, the MyTouch 3G Slide may be a sound choice.
Thanks to a hardware redesign and a software makeover, the MyTouch 3G Slide is "more than just a re-warmed" MyTouch 3G, says Lisa Gade at MobileTechReview.com. The Slide has a larger 3.4-inch touch-screen display with pinch-to-zoom support, a new QWERTY keyboard and bigger 600 MHz processor. Critics praise the bright, responsive screen, and Kenneth Butler at Laptop Magazine says the QWERTY keyboard "hits the sweet spot." Cha likes its spaciousness, but says the slider can be clunky to open. The Slide runs on Android OS 2.1 (Eclair) with two user interfaces: one from HTC and the other from T-Mobile, which users say is more user-friendly. In addition to a guided set-up process, the Slide has Android's multi-panel home screen, Google apps and MS Exchange support. The HTC Sense interface adds five customizable home screens and apps like Friendstream, which combines Facebook, Twitter and Flickr updates. The T-Mobile interface features My Modes, which lets you personalize the home screen for work or home, the Faves Gallery (which keeps track of your 20 favorite people), and the Genius button for voice-recognition searching and messaging, a barcode reader and an bundle of recommended apps.
Focus on messaging
For the most part, the enhancements impress reviewers. MobileTechReview.com's Gade says "it's a pleasure to see a midrange phone get the current goods," while PCMag.com's Sascha Segan likes how it focuses on messaging. But Laptop Magazine's Butler says the Motorola Cliq (Free with new contract) does "a better job of integrating social networking."
The Slide is also a good multimedia phone, according to Segan. It includes a standard Android music player, free DoubleTwist syncing software, a 3.5 mm headphone jack and a YouTube video player. While the 5-megapixel camera gets lukewarm reviews for sub-par image quality, the Slide's browser "notched decent page load times," says Butler. Reviewers report excellent call quality with clear volume and reliable 3G coverage, but battery life -- the most common complaint among users at CNET -- falls short of its rated 7.5 hours in tests at CNET, Laptop Magazine and PCMag.
Laptop Magazine's review provides the most complete comparison to rival smartphones such as the Google Nexus One and HTC Evo 4G. Other professional review sources, including MobileTechReview.com and PCMag.com, make fewer comparisons with rival smartphones but nevertheless deliver thorough evaluations, while user reviews at CNET help to illustrate some of the Slide's drawbacks.
2. T-Mobile Garminfone
An Android smartphone with excellent Garmin GPS
- Outstanding navigation
- Navigates even in dead zones
- Easy user interface
- Includes dash mount/charger
- Older version of Android
- Runs slowly at times
- Blurry photos and video in some tests
- May be too basic for advanced users
Navigation is "fantastic" with the Garminfone, says Tim Stevens at Engadget.com, and other testers agree. While other Android phones such as the Motorola Droid (Free with a new contract) include free turn-by-turn Google Maps Navigation, testers say the Garminfone is a better, more full-featured navigator -- especially since it can navigate regardless of dead zones, unlike the Google Maps version, which must be connected via cell signal to work. The Garminfone comes loaded with North American maps and 6 million points of interest. In a test at Laptop Magazine, it gets a stronger GPS signal than the Droid and is "pretty much identical to a dedicated in-car unit," reviewer Mark Spoonauer says. Directions in your own voice
The Garminfone speaks directions loudly, its 3.5-inch touch screen is easy to see, and testers appreciate the free dash mount/charger that comes in the box. Free traffic reports, weather information, gas prices and movie times are also included. Reviews say the Garminfone has a couple of neat extra features to play with, too. Garmin Voice Studio allows you to record directions in your own voice. And if a friend sends you a text message with an address in it, you can navigate directly there. The Garminfone even remembers where you parked. "This is brilliant stuff," says Jamie Lendino at PCMag.com.
As for handling calls while navigating, reviews say the Garminfone does a smooth job. When you hit the answer button, the Garminfone switches to speakerphone and mutes its navigation prompts while you're talking, although the screen keeps navigating. Everything switches back to normal once you hang up. Call quality is fine in Laptop Magazine's test, although PCMag.com's Lendino says that while callers sounded clear, they "complained that I sounded a little thin and distant."
Smartphone a bit poky and outdated
Smartphone features are where the Garminfone falters in reviews. It's not as powerful as other Android smartphones, such as the Motorola Droid X. With just 256 MB of RAM, "some operations felt sluggish" in PCMag's test. The Garminfone has 4 GB of memory, expandable via microSD card. It runs the older Android 1.6, not the current version, which means it can't run some of the latest Android apps. On the plus side, testers say the Garminfone's simplified interface makes it easy to use, although advanced users will miss some of the usual Android customizations; Engadget.com's Stevens says this is "not a phone for power users." The touch-screen keyboard with haptic feedback works fine in tests.
Lackluster camera
Web pages load quickly over T-Mobile's 3G network in Laptop Magazine's test -- four seconds for NYTimes.com, five seconds for CNN.com, six seconds for ESPN.com -- although sites without mobile versions take longer. Video and photos range from "decent" to "blurry," with a 3-megapixel camera that lacks a flash that Spoonauer calls "far from the cutting edge." PCMag.coms Jamie Lendino neatly sums up reviewer sentiment: "The Garminfone is the nation's best navigation phone, but there are better choices for a general-purpose smartphone."
Reviews of the Garminfone at Laptop Magazine, PCMag.com and Engadget.com are exceptionally thorough, giving the reader an excellent idea of how the phone performs and how it stacks up against the competition. A video review at CNET expertly critiques the phone and shows it in action.
3. Motorola Droid 2
Droid 2 incorporates much-needed updates, but offers few new features
- Android 2.2 improves web browsing
- Easy, responsive navigation
- 3G mobile hotspot for up to five devices
- Improved slide-out keyboard
- 5-megapixel camera
- Stiff keyboard buttons
- Mobile hotspot costs extra
The Android 2.2 "perfectly replicates the desktop experience," PhoneArena.com editors say, thanks to support for the Adobe Flash player. (Most Android smartphones will get this update automatically.) Reviewers praise the Droid 2's toned-down Motoblur interface. PCMag's Sascha Segan says that it's "much less intrusive than Samsung's or HTC's" and will appeal to those looking for a "sparer Android interface." PhoneArena.com calls the Droid 2's screen "nothing that exciting" since the display hasn't changed from the original, but editors are pleased with its responsiveness. Segan rates performance "somewhat faster" than the HTC Droid Incredible (*Est. $80 with new/renewal contract) but "probably be a little slower" than the Samsung Fascinate, another Verizon Android phone.
Responding to complaints about the original Droid, the Droid 2 features a redesigned slide-out QWERTY keyboard that sheds the troublesome D-pad and incorporates bigger, raised keys. It's a bit of a letdown, however, as the keyboard is still "tight" compared to phones such as the Samsung Epic 4G, says PCMag's Sascha Segan, and it still has the "same stiff feeling keys," according to editors at PhoneArena.com. The Droid 2 retains the original Droid's 5-megapixel camera, 720-by-480-pixel video resolution and 3.7-inch TFT capacitive touch screen (854 pixels by 480 pixels). Segan notes that the camera "overexposes shots," though they're still sharp, and finds that the improved 30 frames-per-second video recording (up from 24 fps on the original) presents "smooth and sharp" videos. CNET's Bonnie Cha agrees that pictures are "bright," but feels video quality is "very hazy" even at the highest resolution.
4. Motorola Droid X
Verizon's Droid X leads the Android pack, but may be too big for some
- Huge 4.3-inch display
- Roomy virtual keyboard
- Speedy 1 GHz processor
- Excellent noise-canceling microphones
- Long battery life
- Too big for small hands
- No front-facing camera for video calling
- Sluggish Motoblur interface
The Droid X is slightly taller than the HTC Evo 4 (*Est. $190 with contract), Sprint's flagship Android phone, but it's a tad lighter thinner. "You feel as if you're talking into a frozen waffle," says Pogue, while Ziegler says it's "definitely not for the small of hands." The huge 4.3-inch touch-screen display appears "truly cinematic," says Gade. It packs a higher resolution and a wider aspect ratio than the Evo (16:9 vs. 5:3), says Ziegler, but experts say the Super AMOLED display on the new Samsung Galaxy S, another Android phone due out this fall, may be tough to beat. The Droid X's spacious virtual QWERTY keyboard has optional Swype technology, which lets you type by sliding from key to key, rather than typing. Critics say it's fast and accurate -- albeit a reach for small hands. Most reviewers say that the Droid X is a great choice for most, but note that users with small hands may prefer the slimmer Droid Incredible (*Est. $150 with new contract).
5. HTC EVO 4G
4G Android smartphone hits a few speed bumps
- Huge 4.3-inch display
- First 4G network device
- Fast downloads and media streaming
- Doubles as a personal Wi-Fi hotspot
- Bulky
- Limited 4G coverage
- Extra monthly fees
- Convoluted video chat app
- Paltry battery life
Sprint brands the HTC EVO as the "first" 4G device, even though only 32 metro areas have such coverage and the smartphone switches over to 3G otherwise. The phone uses WiMAX technology to access 4G, but it's solely for data downloads and not phone calls, and WiMAX technology fizzles in urban landscapes. Chris Ziegler at Engadget.com says "we found ourselves getting four bars of 4G walking down the street, then ducking into a coffee shop and dropping to just one or even no bars at all." Sprint also charges EVO owners an additional $10 a month for WiMAX. CNET's Bonnie Cha considers the extra fee reasonable, but says that "making it mandatory for everyone, regardless of whether you live in a 4G market or not, seems unfair."
6. Apple iPhone 4
Apple iPhone 4 leads the smartphone pack, but not by much
- Brilliant high-contrast display
- Powerful 5-megapixel camera
- Unrivaled app store
- Easy FaceTime video calling
- Limited multitasking
- Unreliable reception
- FaceTime restricted to iPhone 4 owners
The buzzworthy feature this time around is FaceTime video calling, which allows you to make face-to-face calls using the VGA camera on the front of the iPhone 4 or the 5-megapixel shooter on back. The technology isn't new, but experts say Apple gets it right. "It's the first phone to make good video calls reliably, with no sign-up or set up, with a single tap," Pogue says, while other critics report it's easier than Android's Fring or Qik apps. However, FaceTime works only on Wi-Fi, and both callers must have an iPhone 4. "That makes FaceTime a special-occasion parlor trick rather than a general purpose solution," says Segan.